Endless Options
More Service

Auto Insurance

Endless Options
More Service

Home Insurance

Endless Options
More Service

Business Insurance

Endless Options
More Service

Life Insurance

Endless Options
More Service

Health Insurance

Coronavirus/COVID-19 UPDATE

Naccarato Insurance is monitoring very closely the develoments of the pandemic crisis.

If you have a specific question about coverage relating to COVID-19, contact Naccarato Insurance at 1-800-823-7134.
You can also contact your carrier directly - phone numbers and websites of our carriers may be found HERE>

For the latest information about COVID-19 visit the Center of Disease Control website HERE>

We Are OPEN!

By phone-email-fax p-845-246-7134 f-845-246-0852

Existing Clients & New Clients
Feel free to leave payments, signed docs, etc. in black lock box by front door – receipts will be mailed.

During these challenging times Naccarato Insurance is prepared to continue to serve our clients. As we continue to monitor the changing landscape created by the COVID-19 pandemic we feel a strong obligation to take measures to work toward keeping both our clients and employees safe by following the suggested safe practice directives conveyed by the Federal Government, State and Local Agencies.
For these reasons, until further notice we will be unable to allow for walk in clientele or in person appointments. However, Naccarato Insurance will continue to commit to making ourselves and resources available to our clients:

We are currently available via phone, email & fax;
There is a black drop box located directly in the front of the building for drop off payments and documents;
Most all of our carriers offer online and phone payment options;
For after hours questions, payments or claims, a list of our carriers and their phone numbers can be located on our website at:

These are unprecedented times and Naccarato Insurance will continue to monitor this situation closely. We are committed to working towards notifying our clients of any changes we make to our operations as this situation continues to evolve.

Office locations

100 Ulster Avenue
Saugerties, NY 12477

108 Main Street, Suite 2
New Paltz, NY 12561

Office hours

Hours of Operation:
9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.

Monday - Friday
Weeknights and weekends
available by appointment.


Follow Us


Susan is my go to for my insurance needs. She just assisted in making a new car purchase painless.
– Thomas Nace

Pam was a wonderful help with my car insurance on Friday afternoon!
– Stephanie Kaufman

I wanted you to know that Mindy has been an amazing help to me. I’ve been dealing with a very difficult situation with another insured’ company. They’ve done everything they can to drag it out (almost 3 months now) and make the situation more awful than necessary. Mindy, however has been a ROCK throughout this ordeal. She has consistently given me sound advice and direction and I don’t know how I would’ve gotten through this without her.
– Rochelle Mosse

Thankful to have found such a friendly, welcoming and professional agency. Lisa Bolde made finding the right policy for me quick and easy. I would highly recommend Naccarato Insurance and Lisa!
– Bri C.

An Independent agency accountably only to you with a full team of support every step of the way!
– Robyn Prosser

Tiffany and Susan are the best. I have nothing nice to say about my actual insurance company but these 2 ladies spent days fighting for me and in the end got damages to my truck covered and tickets dismissed due to the insurance company not standing behind their word. The world needs more people like them.
– Preston Jurkowski

Being in a car accident is upsetting and the 2 times in last few years I had a car incident, I contacted Naccarato. What was so great was their helping to keep me calm, explain what was needed, what likely would be the outcome, and made me feel taken care of. Their staff is excellent in following up, making sure all is ok, and seeing if they can help with anything further. You want these folks on your side when things happen!
– Raleigh Green

Thank you (Naccarato’s) for your continued and generous support, not only with the Hall of Fame but so many others you do annually……….We are most fortunate to have you, along with others, in our community……..It what makes Saugerties so special and unique………Thanks, again!!!
Greg Chorvas, Superintendent
Cantine Veterans Sports Complex”

I am so glad that I switched to Naccarato Insurance. Their customer service is exceptional and they are always working on my behalf by looking out for my best interests. It is a real pleasure doing business with them.
Bryan Golden

For everyone involved in making the purchase of my first house a reality. It’s just the beginning of the American dream for me. Susan, the relationship you have with Sawyer was great. It took me right out of the middle and made it painless. I love this little town we have and how close knit it is to be able to work with all local and friendly people.
Michael Ivino

Endless options, more service.

Sign-up for our emails and blog posts that includes discount information, news, insurance and safety tips and much more

Defensive Driving