Claims & Payments

Accidents are stressful. Filing your claim shouldn’t be. That’s why our account representatives do everything they can to make the process smooth and stress-free. Keep in mind that every loss is different, so the length of time needed to settle a claim varies. Naccarato Insurance is here to help you in every step of the process, and answer any questions you have about your claim.

Naccarato_Insurance_Claims

  • Your contact information
  • Name & contact information of any other party involved
  • Type of loss (auto, home, etc.)
  • Date and place incident occurred
  • Description of the loss
  • Any injuries? Description? To whom?

Claims Contact Information

(Links to Payment Services websites, see below)

Personal Lines

Adirondack Insurance Exchange 1-866-992-4368 (follow prompts)
Allstate 1-800-386-6126
Allstate Flood 1-800-527-2634
American Modern 1-800-543-2644
Carriero & Sons (American Modern Aff) 1-800-777-1344
Dairyland 1-800-526-4252
Donegal 1-800-877-0600 (follow prompts)
Eastern Mutual 1-800-367-3242 (follow prompts)
Encompass 1-800-262-9262 (follow prompts)
Erie & Niagara 1-800-234-9876
Farmer’s Insurance 1-800-435-7764
Finger Lakes 1-800-724-4032 (follow prompts)
Foremost 1-800-527-3905
GMAC 1-800-468-3466
Hagerty 1-800-922-4050
Hartford 1-800-771-8557
Kemper 1-800-357-8999
MSA/NGM 1-877-425-2467
Mercury 1-877-533-6330 (option 1)
MetLife 1-800-255-0332
North Country 1-800-847-7030 (follow prompts)
NY Mutual Underwriters 1-800-962-3155 (follow prompts)
Preferred Mutual 1-800-333-7642 (follow prompts)
Progressive 1-800-274-4499
RLI 1-800-823-7134
Security Mutual 1-800-822-1232 (follow prompts)
Sterling 1-800-462-4661
Tower 1-866-992-4368 (follow prompts)
Travelers 1-800-252-4633
Travelers Flood 1-800-356-6670
Utica First 1-800-456-4556
Utica National 1-800-274-1914

Commercial Lines Claims Contact Information

Allstate Insurance 1-800-255-7828
Apogee 1-877-337-3200
CNA Surety 1-800-331-6053
Countryway 1-800-472-4368
Eastern Mutual 1-800-367-3242 (Ext 227 or 228)
Erie & Niagara 1-800-234-9876 (Ask for claims)
Finger Lakes 1-800-724-4032 (Ask for claims)
First Rehabilitation 1-800-365-4999 (Ask for claims)
GMAC 1-800-468-3466
Hartford 1-800-327-3636
Hartford Steam Boiler 1-800-333-4677
MEMIC 1-800-636-4292
Merchants Mutual 1-800-952-5246
Midrox 1-800-782-0834
MSA/NGM 1-877-425-2467
North Country 1-800-847-7030 (Option 1)
NYMU 1-800-962-3155 (Option 6)
NYSIF 1-877-467-3863
Philadelphia 1-800-765-9749
Preferred Mutual 1-800-333-7642 (X: 1197)
Progressive 1-800-274-4499
Rochdale 1-877-528-7878
Security Mutual 1-800-822-1232 (Ask for claims)
Selective 1-866-455-9969
Sterling 1-800-462-4661 (Ask for claims)
Tower 1-888-856-5522
Travelers 1-800-238-6225
Utica First 1-800-456-4556 (Option 7)
Utica National 1-800-365-1914
Zurich (Disability) 1-800-887-9111
Zurich (Small Business) 1-800-987-3373

Payment Services

Personal Lines Payment Services

Adirondack (Requires Registration) Adirondack Online Bill Payments
Allstate Allstate Online Bill Payments
American Modern AM Online Bill Payments
Auto One AutoOne Online Bill Payments
Dairyland Dairyland Online Bill Payments
Donegal Donegal Online Bill Payments
Eastern Mutual Eastern Online Bill Payments
Encompass Encompass Online Bill Payments
Erie & Niagara E&N Online Bill Payments
Farmers Farmers Online Bill Payments
Finger Lakes Finger Lakes Online Bill Payments
First American Specialty Ins Co http://www.firstam.com
Foremost Foremost Online Bill Payments
GMAC GMAC Online Bill Payments
Hagerty (Requires Registration) Hagerty Online Bill Payments
Hartford (Requires Registration) Hartford Online Bill Payments
Kemper Kemper Online Bill Payments
MSA/NGM MSA/NGM Online Bill Payments
Mercury Casualty Mercury Online Bill Payments
MetLife (Requires Registration) MetLife Online Bill Payments
North Country NCIC Online Bills Payments
NYMU
Preferred Mutual PMI Online Bill Payments
Progressive Progressive Online Bill Payments
RLI RLI Online Bills Payments
Security Mutual SM Online Bill Payments
Sterling Sterling Online Bill Payments
Tower Tower Online Bill Payments
Travelers Travelers Online Bill Payments
Utica First Utica First Online Bill Payments
Utica National Utica National Online Bill Payments

Business/Commercial Lines Payment Services

Allstate Allstate Online Bill Payments
Eastern Mutual Eastern Online Bill Payments
Erie & Niagara E&N Online Bill Payments
Finger Lakes Finger Lakes Online Bill Payments
First Rehabilitation First Rehab Online Bill Payments
GMAC GMAC Online Bill Payments
Hartford (Requires Registration) Hartford Online Bill Payments
MEMIC MEMIC Online Bill Payments
Midrox Midrox Online Bill Payments
MSA/NGM (National Grange) MSA/NGM Online Bill Payments
North Country (Requires Registration) NCIC Online Bills Payments
NYSIF NYSIF Online Bill Payments
Philadelphia Phly Online Bill Payments
Preferred Mutual PMI Online Bill Payments
Progressive Progressive Online Bill Payments
Security Mutual SM Online Bill Payments
Selective Selective Online Bill Payments
Sterling Sterling Online Bill Payments
Tower Tower Online Bill Payments
Travelers Travelers Online Bill Payments
Utica First Utica First Online Bill Payments
Utica National Utica National Online Bill Payments
Zurich (Disability) Zurich DBL Online Bill Payments
Zurich (Small Bus, Requires Registration) Zurich Online Bill Payments

Site design and development by Raleigh Green Inc.